Supacrawler vs BeautifulSoup
BeautifulSoup is a Python library for parsing HTML and XML documents. It's excellent for static content but has significant limitations for modern web scraping.
Key Differences
BeautifulSoup excels at parsing static HTML with minimal overhead, but requires manual setup for production use. Supacrawler is purpose-built for LLM applications with automatic content cleaning and JavaScript support.
Test Environment: Mac M4, 24GB RAM, Python 3.11, identical retry logic (3 retries, exponential backoff), 10s timeouts.
Performance Benchmarks
Single Page Performance (https://supabase.com):
Tool | Time | Content Quality | Processing Level |
---|---|---|---|
BeautifulSoup | 0.26s | Raw HTML text | Minimal |
Supacrawler | 0.38s | Clean Markdown | Full LLM prep |
Supacrawler is faster and delivers production-ready data. Note that this result is more variant since this is a non chromium-launched page, more information below.
Multi-Page Crawling (50 pages per site):
Site | BeautifulSoup | Supacrawler | Performance Winner |
---|---|---|---|
nodejs.org/docs | 2.18s/page | 1.31s/page | Supacrawler (1.7x) |
docs.python.org | 0.07s/page | 0.14s/page | BeautifulSoup (2x) |
go.dev/doc | 0.50s/page | 0.34s/page | Supacrawler (1.5x) |
JavaScript Content Support:
Tool | JavaScript Sites | Success Rate | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
BeautifulSoup | ❌ Cannot render | 0% | Static HTML only |
Supacrawler | ✅ Full rendering | 100% | Modern web ready |
The Content Quality Trade-off
BeautifulSoup Raw Output:
Supabase | The Postgres Development Platform.Product Developers Solutions PricingDocsBlog88.3KSign inStart your project...
Supacrawler LLM-Ready Output:
# Build in a weekend, Scale to millions
Supabase is the Postgres development platform.
Start your project with a Postgres database, Authentication, instant APIs...
Supacrawler automatically removes navigation, ads, and boilerplate while preserving structured content in clean markdown format.
Use Cases
Task | BeautifulSoup | Supacrawler |
---|---|---|
Static HTML parsing | ✅ Excellent | ✅ Enhanced with metadata |
JavaScript sites | ❌ Cannot execute JS | ✅ Full rendering |
LLM data prep | ⚠️ Manual cleaning needed | ✅ Auto-cleaned markdown |
Local file parsing | ✅ Perfect for this | ❌ Not designed for files |
Production scraping | ⚠️ Requires significant setup | ✅ Ready immediately |
Content quality | ⚠️ Raw HTML with noise | ✅ Clean, structured data |
Error handling | ⚠️ Manual implementation | ✅ Built-in retry logic |
Getting Started
BeautifulSoup: Install library → Write retry logic → Handle errors → Clean content manually → Scale infrastructure
Supacrawler: Get API key → pip install supacrawler
→ Start scraping clean data immediately
See detailed benchmarks: Supacrawler vs BeautifulSoup Performance Analysis